A first, 143 years in the making

When the lights of the Metropolitan Opera House began to flicker on October 19, as if the building itself were haunted, Missy Mazzoli was already part of the Met’s history. The Brooklyn-based, Grammy-nominated composer became the first woman to have a world premiere on the company’s stage with Lincoln in the Bardo, an opera commissioned by the Met and adapted from George Saunders’ Booker Prize-winning novel. Brooklyn Magazine framed it as the Met’s first commission and premiere of a new opera by a woman in 143 years. The run at Lincoln Center continues through November 14, and the final performance will be livestreamed on the Met’s YouTube channel.

The libretto is by Royce Vavrek, Mazzoli’s longtime collaborator, who narrowed Saunders’ crowded chorus of voices to five central characters. Lileana Blain-Cruz directed, and Yannick Nézet-Séguin conducted most performances, with Steven Osgood on the podium for two of them.

Ghosts, kazoos and giant puppets

The story is set in 1862 in Oak Hill Cemetery, where the grieving president visits the body of his young son Willie, who is caught in the bardo, the in-between state of Tibetan tradition. Baritone Peter Mattei sang Lincoln, with Everett Sobers as Willie, Christine Goerke as the Reverend, Anthony Roth Costanzo as Miss Elise Traynor, Jonah Hoskins as Bevins, Ryan McKinny as Vollman and Stephanie Blythe among the souls of the graveyard.

The opera opens with a ghostly chorus behind a lace curtain, and the effect is stranger than it looks. Mazzoli told NPR the sound comes from sixty-five trained opera singers playing kazoos. James Ortiz’s giant puppets extend the inner lives of the bardo’s residents, and Raja Feather Kelly choreographed the dancers who linger among the graves. Even the ending was improvised: a planned exit on a live horse was dropped when the animal would not cooperate, Brooklyn Magazine reported, and the team kept the extra music.

A composer who sat with death

Mazzoli brought unusual personal preparation to an opera about the afterlife. She trained as a death doula in 2021, and she has said that experience shaped the scenes in the bardo, according to Brooklyn Magazine. She also spoke frankly about how companies still tend to treat new operas by women as a risk, which is part of why she co-founded the Luna Composition Lab with fellow composer Ellen Reid to mentor composers between 13 and 18.

Saunders, for his part, told the magazine that the novel’s ghosts were inspired by a week he spent in an encampment in 2009, among people who were stuck somewhere they did not choose and longing for the lives they had lost.

A divided reception, a lasting mark

Critics did not agree. The Boston Globe found the production intensely moving, while TheaterMania was far less convinced. Whatever the verdict, a Brooklyn composer has written her name into the Met’s history, and Met general manager Peter Gelb has promised more Mazzoli at the house in the years ahead.

Sources: Brooklyn Magazine; NPR; Bachtrack; The Boston Globe; TheaterMania; AP.